Skip to main content

Table 3 Pre-harvest fruit drop of Hamlin sweet orange trees treated with various SAR inducers in a three-year field trial (2015–2018)

From: Evaluation of the control effect of SAR inducers against citrus Huanglongbing applied by foliar spray, soil drench or trunk injection

Treatment

No. of fruit dropped z

2015

2016

2017

2018

UTC

136 ± 29 a B

149 ± 32 a B

214 ± 43 a A

148 ± 35 a B

ASM spray (0.25 g/tree)

128 ± 26 a B

139 ± 28 a B

217 ± 47 a A

137 ± 33 a B

ASM spray (0.5 g/tree)

139 ± 32 a B

145 ± 31 a B

229 ± 45 a A

147 ± 32 a B

ASM soil drench (0.25 g/tree)

133 ± 27 a B

148 ± 34 a B

237 ± 46 a A

146 ± 29 a B

ASM soil drench (0.5 g/tree)

129 ± 24 a B

141 ± 28 a B

221 ± 41 a A

135 ± 31 a B

ASM injection (0.125 g/tree)

135 ± 32 a B

124 ± 30 a B

216 ± 38 a A

129 ± 33 a B

ASM injection (0.25 g/tree)

143 ± 28 a B

78 ± 21 b C

235 ± 45 a A

69 ± 24 b C

IMI spray (0.25 g/tree)

126 ± 29 a B

139 ± 33 a B

219 ± 36 a A

144 ± 30 a B

IMI spray (0.5 g/tree)

138 ± 31 a B

124 ± 28 a B

228 ± 41 a A

152 ± 37 a B

IMI soil drench (0.25 g/tree)

143 ± 30 a B

132 ± 31 a B

242 ± 48 a A

137 ± 31 a B

IMI soil drench (0.5 g/tree)

132 ± 28 a B

147 ± 35 a B

233 ± 44 a A

144 ± 33 a B

IMI injection (0.125 g/tree)

145 ± 34 a B

131 ± 29 a B

226 ± 39 a A

150 ± 38 a B

IMI injection (0.25 g/tree)

128 ± 29 a B

71 ± 20 b C

215 ± 37 a A

79 ± 21 b C

INA spray (0.25 g/tree)

121 ± 29 a B

138 ± 32 a B

237 ± 48 a A

139 ± 35 a B

INA spray (0.5 g/tree)

137 ± 30 a B

145 ± 35 a B

219 ± 46 a A

70 ± 25 b B

INA soil drench (0.25 g/tree)

129 ± 28 a B

139 ± 32 a B

240 ± 48 a A

142 ± 31 a B

INA soil drench (0.5 g/tree)

140 ± 29 a B

151 ± 31 a B

226 ± 44 a A

133 ± 30 a B

INA injection (0.125 g/tree)

132 ± 31 a B

127 ± 27 a B

215 ± 35 a A

127 ± 34 a B

INA injection (0.25 g/tree)

145 ± 32 a B

72 ± 20 b C

230 ± 43 a A

77 ± 24 b C

SA spray (0.25 g/tree)

136 ± 27 a B

148 ± 32 a B

242 ± 49 a A

129 ± 35 a B

SA spray (0.5 g/tree)

129 ± 30 a B

140 ± 34 a B

227 ± 44 a A

81 ± 22 b C

SA soil drench (0.25 g/tree)

133 ± 27 a B

148 ± 34 a B

237 ± 46 a A

146 ± 29 a B

SA soil drench (0.5 g/tree)

142 ± 32 a B

133 ± 27 a B

222 ± 48 a A

133 ± 33 a B

SA injection (0.125 g/tree)

126 ± 28 a B

140 ± 31 a B

235 ± 44 a A

142 ± 35 a B

SA injection (0.25 g/tree)

141 ± 31 a B

77 ± 23 b C

225 ± 42 a A

69 ± 21 b C

  1. z Data shown are the means ± SD of six replicates (n = 6). Values in the same row followed by different superscript uppercase letters are significantly different within each treatment (P < 0.05). Values in the same column followed by different subscript lowercase letters are significantly different at each sampling time (P < 0.05)